El Nino, a new global warming with the biggest health impact ever seen
The unfolding El Niño event is predicted by climate models to be a major event, possibly one of the strongest ever recorded.
Past events and meteorological data suggest that the risk of severe drought is high in PNG, Solomon Islands, Vanuatu, New Caledonia, Fiji, Tonga and Samoa, while Niue and Cook Island are subject to high risk of drought due to their more eastern location. The risk of drought is also high for Palau, Northern Marianas and Guam, FSM and Marshall Islands.
Above normal rainfall is expected in Kiribati between June and August 2015. There is an elevated risk of intense cyclones, potentially early start and late nish of the cyclone season, and an elevated likelihood of cyclones particularly in Niue, Samoa and Cook Islands (east of Tonga).
Heightened risk of certain vector-borne diseases such as malaria and dengue fever due to an abundance of mosquitoes and decreased immunity due to undernutrition are predicted for all the South East Areas and for India.
Every few years, an unusually warm current flows off the western coast of South America. Its appearance after Christmas lead sailors in Peru to christen it El Nino, the Christ-child in Spanish. Like a child, it is sometimes unpredictable, and sometimes creates havoc. In El Nino’s case, it brings natural disasters such as storms, floods and droughts and famine in far-flung parts of the world.
The term El Nino is nowadays used to refer to the periods of strong and prolonged warm weather, which influence the climate worldwide. The periods of the warm waters in eastern Pacific (El Nino) and periods of cooler waters (La Nina) are accompanied by changes of air pressure in the east and west Pacific: these are called the Southern Oscillation. The whole cycle is now referred to as El Nino Southern Oscillation (ENSO). The effects of La Nina are generally less pronounced and tend to be the opposite of those of El Nino.
- El Nino events occur irregularly, about every 2-7 years.
- They last from 12 to 18 months.
- The El Nino event begins with the weakening of the prevailing winds in the Pacific and a shift in rainfall patterns.
- The events are associated with extreme weather (floods and drought) in countries surrounding the Pacific and much further afield.
- Prolonged dry periods may occur in South-east Asia, Southern Africa and Northern Australia and heavy rainfall, sometimes with flooding, in Peru and Ecuador.
- During a typical El Nino, the Asian monsoon usually weakens and is pushed towards equator, often bringing summer drought to north-west and central regions of India and heavy rainfall in the north-east.
- The regions where El Nino has a strong effect on climate are those with the least resources: southern Africa, parts of South America, South-east Asia.
Health impact and natural disasters
The number of people killed, injured or made homeless by natural disasters is increasing alarmingly. This is partly due to population growth and the concentration of population in high-risk areas like coastal zones and cities. Their vulnerability to extreme weather conditions is also increasing. For example:
- Large shanty towns with flimsy habitations are often located on land subject to frequent flooding.
- In many areas, the only places available to poor communities may be marginal land with few natural defences against weather extremes.
Large year-to-year fluctuations of natural disasters, some of which can be explained by El Nino, are described as the El Nino disaster cycle.
- The risk of a natural disaster is highest in the years during and after the appearance of El Nino and lowest in the years before.
- El Nino events 1982-83 and 1997-98, the most recent, were the largest this century.
- El Nino is associated with death and disease, most of which result from weather-related disasters such as floods and droughts.
- In 1997 Central Ecuador and Peru suffered rainfall more than 10 times normal, which caused flooding, extensive erosion and mudslides with loss of lives, destruction of homes and food supplies.
- In the same year, nearly 10% of all health facilities in Peru were damaged.
- The 1991-92 El Nino brought the worst drought in southern Africa this century, which affected nearly 100 million people.
- Ecuador, Peru and Bolivia suffered serious malaria epidemics after heavy rainfall in 1983 El Nino. The epidemic in Ecuador was badly exacerbated by displacement of the population owing to the flooding.
- The most expensive natural disaster ever, Hurricane Andrew, happened during the same 1991-92 El Nino although El Nino usually reduces hurricane activity.
- During the 1997 El Nino droughts hit Malaysia, Indonesia and Brazil, exacerbating the huge forest fires. Smoke inhalation from these fires was a major public health problem in these countries, with countless people visiting health facilities with respiratory problems.
Recently, there has been growing recognition of the links between El Nino and disease. For example, doctors for many years were intrigued by the cycles of malaria in some countries roughly every 5 years. Such cycles in India, Venezuela and Columbia have now been linked to El Nino. Pronounced changes in the incidence of epidemic diseases can occur in parallel with extreme weather conditions associated with the El Nino cycle.
El Nino and epidemic diseases
The El Nino cycle is associated with increased risks of some of the diseases transmitted by mosquitoes, such as malaria, dengue and Rift Valley fever. Malaria transmission is particularly sensitive to weather conditions. In dry climates, heavy rainfall can create puddles, that provide good breeding conditions for mosquitoes. In very humid climates, droughts may turn rivers into strings of pools, preferred breeding sites of other types of mosquito .
Generalizations about the association between vector-borne disease transmission and El Nino are not easy, as local transmission depends on ecology of the local vector species, whose responses to timing and amount of rainfall may differ.
- Malaria is increasing and resurgent in areas where it had formerly been controlled.
On the desert and highland fringes of malarious areas, rainfall, humidity and temperature are critical parameters for disease transmission. In these places malaria transmission is unstable and the population lacks protective immunity. Thus, when weather conditions favour transmission, serious epidemics may occur.
In some highland regions higher temperatures possibly linked to El Nino may increase malaria transmission. This has been shown to occur in higher latitude parts of Asia, such as northern Pakistan. At the beginning of this century, periodic epidemics of malaria flared up in Punjab region (north-east Pakistan and north-west India) after excessive monsoon rainfall.
Before the advent of DDT for malaria control, the risk of malaria in Punjab increased five times following an El Nino.
From 1921, forecasts of malaria epidemics in that region were based on established relationship between rainfall and malaria mortality, creating probably the first malaria early warning system. Malaria is now controlled in Punjab, but it is still a serious problem in more arid areas in Western Rajasthan and Gujarat in India and Pakistan. There, too, the epidemics are linked to excessive rainfall. However, in some regions, malaria epidemics are linked to below-average rainfall.
- In Venezuela and Colombia, malaria cases increase by more than one third following dry conditions associated with El Nino.
- In Sri Lanka, in pre-DDT times, the risk of malaria increased three-fold following the failure of the monsoon which was also associated with El Nino.
- In Southern Africa, countries have recently experienced malaria epidemics following unusual rainfall.
Dengue is the most important viral tropical disease transmitted by mosquitoes.
The mosquitoes that transmit dengue breed in containers and are less sensitive to rainfall patterns, but higher temperatures associated with El Nino may have an effect on the transmission of the virus. The connection between the weather conditions and dengue transmission and outbreaks is not yet clear; even if the weather conditions were favourable for transmission, the local population may be already immune to the prevalent virus.
Preliminary studies have shown a link between the El Nino Southern Oscillation and incidence of dengue in countries where the El Nino Southern Oscillation has a strong effect on the weather (e.g. some Pacific Island nations and Indonesia). In 1998, many countries in Asia suffered an unusually high level of dengue and dengue haemorrhagic fever, some of which may be attributable to El Nino-related extreme weather.
Outbreaks of Australian Encephalitis (Murray Valley Encephalitis – MVE), another mosquito-transmitted disease, occur in temperate south-east Australia after heavy rainfall and flooding associated with La Nina events. There is some evidence that outbreaks of Ross River virus infection are linked with La Nina also, but this is less certain that in the case of MVE. The public health impact of Ross River infection is greater than MVE in terms of number of people affected.
Rift Valley fever
Rift Valley Fever (RVF) is a mosquito-transmitted viral disease, which primarily affects cattle, but can spread to the local human population. Outbreaks of human disease in eastern Africa always follow episodes of heavy rain (although in that region, El Nino is not always associated with heavy rainfall). A severe outbreak of disease occurred following excessive rainfall in north-eastern Kenya and southern Somalia during the 1997-98 El Nino. The rainfall patterns were unusually heavy for El Nino, resulting in flooding and major outbreaks of malaria and cholera.
El Nino forecasts
A focus of research is centred on the ability to predict El Nino events several months in advance. Seasonal forecasts (also called El Nino forecasts) are used to predict major climate trends for anything from several months to a few seasons ahead. A seasonal forecast usually describes the probability of weather factors (temperature, rainfall) being above, near or below the average. Such forecasts are much more reliable during El Nino, because of its strong effect on climate. These forecasts are only experimental at the moment, but their accuracy and reliability is expected to improve in the near future.
Because El Nino events evolve over several months, it is already possible to give advanced warning of many impacts once the onset of an event has been confirmed.
El Nino and global warming
Global warming is one of the most serious threats to our environment. Although we do not know how climate change may affect El Nino, it has been suggested that the phenomenon may become more intense or more frequent.
A report by a WHO Task Group has warned that climatic change may have important impact on human health. It is likely that the frequency and intensity of weather events around the world will be affected.
The El Nino Southern Oscillation phenomenon provides good opportunities to study effects of climate variability on human health.
WHO is a member of the United Nations Inter-Agency Task Force on El Nino. The Task Force aims to develop a strategy towards prevention, preparedness and mitigation of El Nino-induced disasters. In order to reduce the impact of the next El Nino, the United Nations has asked for intergovernmental agencies support in activities of the International Decade for Natural Disaster Reduction and for its successor arrangement, the International Strategy for Disaster Reduction.
Seasonal forecasting is increasingly used to provide early warning of drought. There is a need for collaboration between meteorological and health sectors to produce health early warning systems.
A pilot study on the application of seasonal forecasting to malaria control has been undertaken in the Southern Africa Development Community region. In this study, the national meteorological services, health sector and agriculture sector have joined forces.
WHO has recently launched a new initiative to combat malaria-“Roll Back Malaria”. Targeting control efforts to years when there is a high-risk of El Nino increases the cost-effectiveness of malaria control; also, the judicious use of insecticides can delay the development of resistance.